FBA vs FBM: Which is better for you?

The best option between FBA and FBM depends on your logistical needs, profit margins, and business goals. While FBA is ideal for scalability and Prime, FBM is perfect for control and lower costs. If you’re already selling on Amazon or planning to do so, you’ve likely encountered the decision between FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) and FBM (Fulfillment by Merchant). This choice directly impacts your business’s logistics, profit margins, delivery times, and customer satisfaction.

My name is Jordi Ordóñez, and I want to dive into the differences, advantages, and disadvantages of each option so you can make the best decision for your business.

What is FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon)?

FBA is Amazon’s logistics system where they handle almost everything: storage, order preparation, shipping, and customer service. All you need to do is send your inventory to one of their fulfillment centers, and they take care of the rest.

Advantages of FBA

1. Access to Prime and greater visibility: FBA-managed products are eligible for Amazon Prime, offering faster and free shipping to millions of users. This significantly increases your listing’s conversion rate.
2. Optimized logistics: Amazon has one of the most advanced logistics networks in the world. This means you can provide fast and reliable delivery without the hassle of managing shipping yourself.
3. Scalability: If your business grows rapidly, FBA adapts seamlessly. You don’t need to worry about hiring staff, renting warehouses, or handling bulk shipments.
4. Customer service: Amazon manages returns and customer inquiries, saving you time and improving the buying experience.

Disadvantages of FBA

1. High costs: Storage and shipping fees for FBA can take a significant chunk out of your margins, especially if you sell large, heavy, or slow-moving products.
2. Limited control: Once you send your inventory to Amazon, you lose some control over how your products are managed, particularly in areas like customized packaging.
3. Inventory restrictions: Amazon imposes storage limits, especially during peak seasons like Black Friday or Christmas. This can be a problem if you have a large inventory.

What is FBM (Fulfillment by Merchant)?

In the FBM model, you (the seller) handle all the logistics yourself. This includes storing inventory, preparing orders, and shipping them directly to customers. While it requires more effort, it gives you complete control over the process.

Advantages of FBM

1. Complete control: You decide how to package products, negotiate with carriers, and manage returns. This is ideal if you sell fragile items or products that require special packaging.
2. Lower costs: By avoiding Amazon’s storage and shipping fees, you can save money, especially if you already have your own logistics system in place.
3. Inventory flexibility: You’re not limited by Amazon’s storage restrictions, allowing you to manage your stock according to your needs.

Disadvantages of FBM

1. Extra effort: Handling logistics yourself involves more work. If your sales volume grows, managing it without additional resources can be challenging.
2. No Prime access: FBM products are not eligible for Amazon Prime (unless you use the Seller Fulfilled Prime program, which comes with its own challenges), which can impact conversions.
3. Lower competitiveness: FBM products often rank lower in search results compared to FBA listings, as Amazon prioritizes Prime-eligible items.

Key differences between FBA and FBM

One of the best ways to understand these differences is through a comparison table:

Aspect	FBA	FBM
Logistics management	Amazon handles everything	You manage everything
Prime eligibility	Yes	No (except with Seller Fulfilled Prime)
Costs	High storage and fulfillment fees	Depends on your logistics setup
Control	Limited	Total
Scalability	Very high	Depends on your resources
Customer service	Handled by Amazon	You handle it

How to choose between FBA and FBM

The choice between FBA and FBM depends on several factors related to your business model, resources, and goals.

Factors to consider

1. Sales volume: If you sell a high volume of products, FBA might be a simpler and more scalable option. However, if your sales are more modest, FBA’s costs may be prohibitive.
2. Profit margins: Low-margin products might not be profitable with FBA due to its fees. In this case, FBM might be a better fit.
3. Product type: Selling large or heavy items can lead to high FBA fees. On the other hand, FBA can be more efficient for small, lightweight products.
4. Existing infrastructure: If you already have warehouses and a logistics system in place, FBM could be more cost-effective. But if you’re starting from scratch, FBA can save you a lot of initial time and effort.

Scenarios where FBA is the best option

• High-turnover products: Items that sell quickly, like gadgets, toys, or books, are ideal for FBA since storage fees don’t accumulate.
• Businesses with limited logistics resources: If you lack infrastructure for inventory and shipping management, FBA lets you outsource these tasks.
• Need for fast delivery: If your customers value Prime shipping, FBA is almost essential.

Scenarios where FBM is the best option

• Niche or customized products: If you sell items that require special packaging or cater to a specific audience, FBM provides the necessary control.
• Large and heavy items: FBA’s storage and shipping fees can be prohibitive for these products.
• Moderate sales volume: If your sales don’t justify FBA’s costs, FBM offers a more economical solution.

Costs associated with FBA and FBM

FBA costs

• Storage fees: Based on the size and weight of your products, with increases during peak seasons.
• Fulfillment fees: A fixed cost per item shipped, including packaging and shipping.
• Additional fees: For example, long-term storage or returns.

FBM costs

• Shipping: Shipping expenses depend on your agreements with carriers.
• Infrastructure: Costs related to warehouses, logistics software, and staff.
• Time: Managing logistics consumes resources, which is also a cost.

Pros and cons summarized

FBA

• Pros: Scalability, Prime eligibility, automated management.
• Cons: High costs, less control.

FBM

• Pros: Total control, lower costs.
• Cons: More work, no Prime eligibility.

The answer depends on your needs and resources. If you’re looking for simplicity, scalability, and Prime access, FBA is the way to go. If you prefer maintaining control and minimizing costs, FBM might be a better fit. You can also combine both models, depending on the type of product you sell.

I hope this analysis has clarified the differences between FBA and FBM. Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but making the right choice can make all the difference for your business. See you in the next article!

More posts